T2R1: x nayatrei x versus deadgiveaway

[NISHA LAMHEAD]

If you voted in the previous topic, please please please vote again.

x nayatrei x (Kathy):


deadgiveaway (Pamela):



RULES:
Round theme was "lost love."
Vote in this format - [insertnamehere] GMV.
Try to put why you voted for them/what you liked about their banner/suggestions for both entries.
First one with 10 votes advances.
Vote only no discussion.

[cellosweet x)]

Pamela GMV.

I liked both banners, but what made me like Pam's better than Kathy's is the text on Kathy's. I just didn't like it there. I really didn't like the font, either.. Also, I felt Pamela's graphic was a bit.. cleaner, I guess? I'm not sure as to how to say it..

[xYunaxFantasiesX]

Kathy gmv
It had more emotion shown through the images and the typography. The signature has a nice contrast and suprisingly depth. The only fault for me was the signature size and the image could have been blended in better.

Pamela's was also good but it didn't left an impression on me which it could have if there were text. It seems very flat and almost no depth, the texture is very obvious for me and the dark spot at the top right hand corner threw off the flow.

[Light Disciple]

Kathy GMV

I think they are equal when it comes to ability and style but I think that Kathy portrayed the theme better.

[IVY LAMHEAD]

Kathy gets my vote.

Kathy, I like the pictures you used to portray the theme. It matches well, and the colors match nicely. Nice. :]

Pamela, I like yours too. It seems like a mother-child lost love type thing...yea. xP It's definately unique, compared with the other themes. I would have liked it better if you had text, like Yuna said. Good job to you too. x]

[façade]

Kathy GMV.

I think that Kathy's portrayal of the theme fit better. Pamela's is pretty, but I don't really see the theme in it.

[radicalhyper]

Kathy GMV

I thought both were equally wonderful, but Kathy's stood out the most, or at least in my opinion. Pamela's was a little empty for me, and Kathy's was just the right amount of activity in the banner. Had the words, had the feeling.

They were both wonderful, but Kathy gets my vote this time.